An argument against english only policy in the united states

Actor, comedian, activist and art collector English Only! And y'all know how much them "Messi-cans" like to make babies. For English, stay on the line.

An argument against english only policy in the united states

Does official English advance the former or later? Censusby providing a common means of communication. Steve Balich, the Homer, Illinois township's clerk and author of a July resolution calling for official English: It's really as simple as that" [2] This is a common provision in many countries abroad, and a reasonable request by a government and nation that has always conducted its official governing in English.

But, it is another thing entirely for a citizen to demand these services as a right. Official English has nothing to do with discrimination.

An argument against english only policy in the united states

This isn't about race. People from every race come to the US and learn to understand the American dialect of English. Suggesting learning English is too hard for some is racist. Suggesting that learning English is easy for some races and difficult for other races is, itself, racist.

Anybody can learn English. It is not too high of a burden to ask them to do so in order to live in the United States. Choice exists to learn language; Official English not discrimination. Real forms of discrimination aim at the inherent characteristics of an individual that they cannot change such as their skin color or national origin.

But, language is different, as an individual can choose to learn English. If they feel disadvantaged because they are not able to read government documents, ballots, or defend themselves in court, it is fully their choice to change this by learning English.

Too many languages for right to govt services in own language. There are over three hundred languages spoken in the United States. Giving all of those individuals, in all of those different languages, the right to demand government services in their own language is preposterous.

If we give Spanish speaking people this right, we would naturally have to extend the right to all the other some-odd languages and those that speak them. This would unreasonably burden government services, adding a huge layer of bureaucracy and costs. Even then, inevitably, somebody with some obscure language will find that their "right" to have services provided to them in their own language will not be adequately fulfilled at some government facility.

This is a bad combination in public policy; a right that cannot be provided adequately that nevertheless adds billions of dollars in extra costs for US government and taxpayers. This has been the effect, for example, of the efforts of the English to impose the English language in Ireland, of Soviet efforts to impose the Russian language on non-Russian nationalities, and of Franco's efforts to impose Spanish on the Basques and Catalans.

Switzerland has four official languages: French, German, Italian and Romansh. All four languages have equal status and children are educated in the language spoken in the region where they live.

And, Switzerland is a country that has very strong unity and economic functionality. Section of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of bans discrimination based "on the ground of race, color, or national origin," in "any program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.

Big Issues

For example, John Tanton, the founder of the main political lobbying organization in this movement called US English, had to resign in after making derogatory remarks about Hispanics. As a sign of respect to all these people it should not limit its citizens by introducing English as the only official language.

Official English degrades image of other languages It gives the impression that English is more important than other languages, thereby devaluing them.Nov 16,  · "English Only" Laws Divide and Demean I argue that making English the official language in the United States or any state is about as necessary as establishing popcorn as .

Answerbag: "Should English be the official language of the United States?" "Should English be America’s Official Language?" by JeremyPlo on January 25, , with many comments.

"Eloquent debate against English only bill." United Vision for Idaho. March 07, ; Ernie Suggs. "Groups lobby against English-only driver's license test." AJC. Aug 14,  · This is the first part of an article "English Only" written by actor, director, and art advocate Cheech Marin.

"Para Español, oprima el numero dos. For English, stay on . The English-only movement, also known as the Official English movement, is a political movement for the use of only the English language in official United States government operations through the establishment of English as the only official language in the US.

The US has never had a legal policy proclaiming an official national language. U.S. English is a national, non-partisan, non-profit citizens' group whose mission is to preserve the role of the English language in the United States and make it the official language of the government, thereby encouraging immigrants to learn English (U.S.


An argument against english only policy in the united states

The English-only movement and the arguments used by its supporters to justify their actions are very similar to those used at other times and in other places to force the domination of one group over another.

Debate: English as US official language - Debatepedia